Australian Capital Territory Numbered Acts

[Index] [Table] [Search] [Search this Act] [Notes] [Noteup] [Previous] [Download] [Help]

DISCRIMINATION AMENDMENT ACT 2016 (NO. 49 OF 2016) - SCHEDULE 1

Schedule 1     Consequential amendments

(see s 3)

Part 1.1     Criminal Code 2002

[1.1]     New chapter 7A

insert

Chapter 7A     Other offences

750     Serious vilification

    (1)     A person commits an offence if—

        (a)     the person intentionally carries out an act; and

        (b)     the act is a threatening act; and

        (c)     the person is reckless about whether the act incites hatred toward, revulsion of, serious contempt for, or severe ridicule of, a person or group of people on the ground of any of the following:

              (i)     disability;

              (ii)     gender identity;

              (iii)     HIV/AIDS status;

              (iv)     race;

              (v)     religious conviction;

              (vi)     sexuality; and

        (d)     the act is done other than in private; and

        (e)     the person is reckless about whether the act is done other than in private.

Examples—other than in private

1     screening recorded material at an event that is open to the public, even if privately organised

2     writing a publically viewable post on social media

3     speaking in an interview intended to be broadcast or published

4     actions or gestures observable by the public

5     wearing or displaying clothes, signs or flags observable by the public

Note     An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears (see Legislation Act

, s 126 and s 132).

Maximum penalty: 50 penalty units.

    (2)     In this section:

"disability"—see the Discrimination Act 1991

, section 5AA.

"gender identity"—see the Discrimination Act 1991

, dictionary.

"HIV/AIDS" status means status as a person who has the Human Immunodeficiency Virus or Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome.

"race"—see the Discrimination Act 1991

, dictionary.

"religious conviction"—see the Discrimination Act 1991

, dictionary.

"sexuality"—see the Discrimination Act 1991

, dictionary.

"threatening act" means an act carried out by a person only if the person—

        (a)     by the act, intentionally threatens physical harm toward, or toward any property of, the person, or members of the group mentioned in subsection (1) (c) (i) to (vi); or

        (b)     is reckless about whether the act incites others to threaten the harm.

[1.2]     New section 750 (1) (c) (iiia)

insert

        (iiia)     intersex status;

[1.3]     Section 750 (2), new definition of intersex status

insert

"intersex status"—see the Discrimination Act 1991

, dictionary.

Part 1.2     Human Rights Commission Act 2005

[1.4]     Section 42 (1) (c)

substitute

        (c)     a complaint about an unlawful act under the Discrimination Act 1991

(a discrimination complaint );

[1.5]     New section 42 (1A)

insert

    (1A)     For a discrimination complaint, the complaint may be made in relation to unfavourable treatment—

        (a)     on the grounds of 2 or more attributes under the Discrimination Act 1991

, section 7; and

        (b)     occurring on 2 or more occasions.

[1.6]     Section 42 (1A)

omit

attributes under the Discrimination Act 1991

, section 7

substitute

protected attributes under the Discrimination Act 1991

[1.7]     New section 43 (1) (ea)

insert

        (ea)     if the complaint is a discrimination complaint—a person who has a sufficient interest in the complaint; or

[1.8]     New section 43 (1A)

insert

    (1A)     For subsection (1) (ea), a person has a sufficient interest in a complaint if the conduct complained about is a matter of a genuine concern to the person because of the way conduct of that kind adversely affects, or has the potential to adversely affect, the interests of the person or interests or welfare of anyone the person represents.

[1.9]     New section 43 (4A)

insert

    (4A)     A person mentioned in subsection (1) (ea) may make a complaint only if the aggrieved person consents to the making of the complaint.

[1.10]     New section 44 (1) (ba)

insert

        (ba)     if the complaint is made by a person under section 43 (1) (ea)—name the aggrieved person; and

[1.11]     New section 44 (1A)

insert

    (1A)     For a discrimination complaint, the complaint need not state whether the discrimination complained about is direct discrimination or indirect discrimination.

Note     Discrimination occurs when a person directly or indirectly discriminates against someone (see Discrimination Act 1991

, s 8).

[1.12]     Section 53

substitute

53     Meaning of unlawful act —div 4.2A

In this division:

"unlawful act" means an unlawful act under the Discrimination Act 1991

.

[1.13]     New section 53CA

insert

53CA     Onus of establishing complaint about discrimination etc

    (1)     This section applies to a discrimination complaint, referred to the ACAT under this division, about discrimination by a person against another person by—

        (a)     treating, or proposing to treat, the other person unfavourably because of a protected attribute of the other person ( direct discrimination ); or

        (b)     imposing, or proposing to impose, a condition or requirement that has, or is likely to have, the effect of disadvantaging the other person because of a protected attribute of the other person (other than a condition or requirement that is reasonable in the circumstances) ( indirect discrimination ).

    (2)     It is a rebuttable presumption that discrimination has occurred if the complainant—

        (a)     establishes that—

              (i)     for a complaint about direct discrimination—the treatment or proposed treatment is unfavourable; and

              (ii)     for a complaint about indirect discrimination—the condition or requirement has, or is likely to have, an effect of disadvantaging the other person; and

        (b)     presents evidence that would enable the ACAT to decide, in the absence of any other explanation—

              (i)     for a complaint about direct discrimination—that the treatment or proposed treatment is because of a protected attribute of the other person; or

              (ii)     for a complaint about indirect discrimination—that the effect of disadvantaging the other person is because of a protected attribute of the other person.

    (3)     The presumption under subsection (2) is rebutted if the person complained about establishes that—

        (a)     for a complaint about direct discrimination—the treatment is not because of a protected attribute of the other person; or

        (b)     for a complaint about indirect discrimination—the effect of disadvantaging a person is not because of a protected attribute of the other person.

Note     The onus of establishing an exception or exemption to discrimination is on the person seeking to rely on it (see Discrimination Act 1991

, s 70).

    (4)     In this section:

"protected attribute" means an attribute mentioned in the Discrimination Act 1991

, section 7.

[1.14]     Section 53CA (4)

omit

an attribute mentioned in the Discrimination Act 1991

, section 7

substitute

a protected attribute under the Discrimination Act 1991

[1.15]     New section 53DA

insert

53DA     Commission to give information etc to ACAT

The commission must give the ACAT (if asked by it) any information or copies of documents in relation to a complaint referred to the ACAT under this division, other than—

        (a)     a communication or document to which section 66 (Admissibility of evidence) applies; or

        (b)     information, a document or something else relevant to a consideration in relation to a complaint given to the commission under section 73 (Power to ask for information, documents and other things); or

        (c)     information given to the commission under section 74 (Requiring attendance etc).

[1.16]     New section 53E (2A) and (2B)

insert

    (2A)     In making an order under subsection (2) (c), the ACAT must consider—

        (a)     the person's right to equality before the law and the impact of the discrimination on the enjoyment of that right; and

        (b)     the inherent dignity of all people and the impact of the discrimination on the person's dignity; and

        (c)     the public interest in ensuring an appropriate balance between the right to equal and effective protection against discrimination and equality before the law without distinction or discrimination and other human rights; and

        (d)     the nature of the discrimination; and

        (e)     any mitigating factors.

Examples—par (b)—impact of discrimination

distress, humiliation, loss of self-esteem, loss of enjoyment of life

Example—par (c)—other human rights

freedom of expression

Examples—par (d)

serious or repeated discrimination, intentional or malicious discrimination, discrimination on the grounds of 2 or more attributes mentioned in the Discrimination Act 1991

, s 7

Examples—par (e)

a public apology, systemic changes to protect against further discrimination

Note     An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears (see Legislation Act

, s 126 and s 132).

    (2B)     The commission may, with the ACAT's consent, intervene in a complaint to make submissions about an order under subsection (2) (c).

[1.17]     Section 53E (2A), examples—par (d)

omit

attributes mentioned in the Discrimination Act 1991

, s 7

substitute

protected attributes under the Discrimination Act 1991

[1.18]     Section 78 (2) (c) (iv), example

omit

unlawful under the Discrimination Act 1991

, part 3, part 5, section 66 or part 7

substitute

an unlawful act under the Discrimination Act 1991

[1.19]     New section 99 (6)

insert

    (6)     A person to whom this section applies does not commit an offence under subsection (2) only because the person discloses information in relation to a discrimination complaint if—

        (a)     the person discloses the information in exercising a function under this Act in relation to education or research; and

        (b)     all relevant parties consent to the information being disclosed.

Part 1.3     Legal Aid Act 1977

[1.20]     Section 68A (9), definition of unjustified discrimination

omit

unlawful

substitute

an unlawful act

Part 1.4     Protection of Public Participation Act 2008

[1.21]     Section 7 (2) (b)

after

Discrimination Act 1991

insert

, section 67A

[1.22]     New section 7 (2) (ba)

insert

        (ba)     that constitutes an offence against the Criminal Code

, section 750 (Serious vilification); or

Part 1.5     Road Transport (Public Passenger Services) Regulation 2002

[1.23]     Section 62 (2), note

omit

s 9

substitute

s 5AA

Part 1.6     Spent Convictions Act 2000

[1.24]     Section 3 (2), note

omit

[1.25]     Section 3 (3), new note

insert

Note     See the Discrimination Act 1991

, s 7 (1) (l) for discrimination on the ground of spent conviction or extinguished conviction.



AustLII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback